Concern over truck flip on wire rope barriers

Truck wire rope barriers WRBs

Concern for the safety of all motorists, including motorcyclists, has been expressed in the wake of a fatal truck flip over wire rope barriers near Melbourne this morning (4 November 2019).

The truck hit the wire rope barriers (WRBs) on the Princes Freeway at Werribee South about 3.20am, flipped over and landed on its roof, killing the driver.

Truck wire rope barriers WRBs
(Above two images courtesy Seven Network)

One year ago a Bad Roads Rally in Melbourne called for the immediate halt to the rollout of WRBs.

Other states are also adding more WRBs, including NSW where they are being installed on the Pacific Highway at Chinderah in the far north of the state. The work is expected to be completed in about five weeks with traffic reduced to one lane.

wire rope barriers WRBs
New wire rope barriers at Chinderah

Runoff, not barriers

University of Melbourne (Honorary) Professorial Fellow and bike rider Prof Richard Huggins says “motorcycle safety requires runoff areas rather than barriers”.

“If there must be barriers, it must be demonstrated that in the event of a crash they are less injurious to riders than if there were no barriers,” he says.

The professor points out that European research found that the rider was still  upright on impact in half of all crashes and was thrown over the barrier.

“After this morning’s crash it seems trucks and other large vehicles flipping over the barriers is similarly not considered,” he says.”

wire rope barriers WRBs
Installing WRBs

The Australian Motorcycle Council believes that any safety barrier construction in Australia should be “of a standard and a fit to cause the least injury to a rider or pillion than if there were no barrier”.  

“WRBs have been shown to be more dangerous to riders than other types of barrier and are less likely to meet this criteria,” they say.

In the AMC position statement, they say there is not enough research into the effect of WRBs and they refute authorities’ claims that WRBs are cheaper.

“A Swedish research paper has studied the ‘whole of life’ costs of barriers and found that wire rope barrier is the most expensive, probably due to it having to repaired after minor impacts,” they claim.

 

3 Comments

  1. Wire rope barriers…. the roadside giant Deli meat slicer for the motorcyclist.
    Yes, run off areas everywhere, even in cities we have concrete islands & barriers to block any ability to avoid collision & injuries.

  2. These Tensioned wire cables are death to a motorcycle rider no doubt, & only when a truck or vehicle has a fatal accident it’s assessed. Absolutely disgraceful so called safety barrier!
    The designer & approver had no sense of real world road safety!

  3. Who is getting rich off these inferior barriers?
    They are so crap at every aspect of being a barrier that corruption is the only explanation for the overzealous deployment of these totally worthless things.
    No barrier is perfect but WRBs are the least perfect in all areas.
    The primary target of these barriers is preventing head on collisions by passenger vehicles, if you’re driving an American style vehicle of the 80s they might actually work, but for every other vehicle on the road they add the danger of either providing no barrier at all or trapping the occupants in a vehicle while cutting open the fuel tank.
    It is very clear from more recent testing and real life failures that the only thing that should be done with these barriers is scrap them and charge the criminals who are getting rich while killing people.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.